April, 2001

Hepatitis E: Review of a disease endemic in Pakistan

  F. Shahzad, M. Atiq, S. Ejaz  ( Depaetment 0f Medical Students, The Aga Khan University, Karachi. )
S. Hameed  ( Depaetment 0f Medicine, The Aga Khan University, Karachi. )


The primary hepatotrophic viruses (hepatitis A. B. C, D and E virus) are the most common cause of acute liver disease1. In developing countries the majority of these cases are caused by the hepatitis E virus (HEV)2,3. Hepatitis E is enterically transm itted, causing a self-limiting disease similar to hepatitis A. It is endemic in most developing countries, where it causes major epidemics and sporadic cases.
Epidemics of hepatitis E are thought to have occurred in Europe and the United States in the 18th and 19th centuries4. However. HEV was recognized as a separate disease in the early eighties when sera of patients from epidemics of viral hepatitis in Delhi and Kashmir were found to lack serological markers of acute hepatitis A or B and it was referred to as enterically transmitted non-A, non-B hepatitis5. The proof of its existence came in 1983 when virus-like particles were detected h\\ immune electron microscopy from the faeces of a person infected with enterically transmitted non-A. non-B hepatitis6.
The genome of HEV was cloned in 1990 and fully sequenced subsequently7.
The WHO recognizes Hepatitis E as a significiant health problem in many developing nations. Pakitan is endemic for all types of hepatitis and hepatitis E occurs here in both sporadic and endemic forms. Documented epidemics have occurred in Sargodha (1987)8, Abbotabad (1988)9 and lslamabad (1993)10. Some recent studies have shown 11EV to be the most common etiologic agent of sporadic hepatitis in Pakistan2.
Hepatitis F virus is endemic in developing countries. Several outbreaks have been reported from South Asia11. Middle East12, northern Africa13, and Central Asia14. Outbreaks usually occur after rainy seasons, flooding and recession of floodwatersb.15 They have also been associated with poor hygiene16 and unsafe water supplies11,16. An epidemic of hepatitis E infecting 3.827 people occurred in Islamabad after a water treatment plant broke down10.
Young to middle aged individuals between 15 and 40 years of age have the highest attack rates17. Males and females have been shown to be equally susceptible in acquiring hepatitis E However. some reports have shown a >3 times higher attack rate in males 1 5. AttacL rates during an epidemic vary froni 1% to 15%5,19,20. The case fatality rate from the general population is from 0.5% to 4%16-18.
Hepatitis E is especially severe in pregnancy. The attack rates in pregnant females have been reported from 17% to 40%18,21. Pregnant females in the second and third trimesters exhibit a case fatality rate of 20%15,16,22,23. Frequency of abortions, stillbirths and neonatal deaths is aiso increased in pregnant women with hepatitis infection19. Flowever, this appears to be true only thr developing countries because reports from Europe and USA have shown that the course of viral hepatitis in pregnancy is in no way different from that in non-pregnant women24-26. Altered immune response. hormonal changes associated with pregnancy and malnutrition have been postulated as the possible factors responsible for the increased severity of the disease during pregnancy27. None of the reports however have been able to conclusively attribute the fulminant course of the disease to these factors.
HEV is a RNA virus, provisionally classified in the family caliciviridae, genus calicivirus on the basis of its structural and physicochemical properties28. It bears a closer resemblance to rubella virus and plant fUroviruses in its genomic organization29. It is a single standard positive sense RNA molecule approximately 7.5 kh in length. The genes of 15 isolates have been fully sequenced. The are classified in 5 genotypes: genotype-I (Asta-Africa), genotype-Il (United States). genotype-Ill (Mexico). genotype-lV (Beijing. China) and genotype V (Europe)9.
Genotype I is the most complex. having 2 sub-genotypes: African and Asian. The Asian sub-genotype comprises of 2 genetic clusters: South Asian and Central Asian. The South Asian cluster includes isolates froni Burma. India. Pakistan and Nepal. The Central Asian cluster includes isolates froiii China. Pakistan, Kirghistan and Uzbckistan9.
In Pakistan, two phylogenetically distinct variants have been identified. The Sargodha isolate (Sar-55) belonging to the central Asian clusters of genotype I was identified in a 1987 epidemic8. Abbotabad isolate (Abb-2b) which was subsequently identified from an epidemic in 1998 has been placed in the South Asian clusters of genotype I. The two Pakistani isolates were recovered 18 months apart from cities only 3000 kilometers from each other, but because they are also so distinct they must have had separate origin9. There are many examples of travelers importing HEV30,31 The geography of South Asia does not provide a barrier to the movement of the HEV from east to west, whereas unfavorable geography renders travel from Central Asia to Pakistan less frequent. Thus speculated that Abb-2b represent HEV endemic in Pakistan while Sar-55 was an unusual introduction from China9.
HEV is transmitted almost exclusively by the fecal­oral route11,15,16. Person to person transmission appears to be distinctly uncommon32. Nosocomial spread of hepatitisE has been reported in a hospital in South Africa33.
Hepatitis E occurs in both epidemic and sporadic forms. Most epidemics of hepatitis E have occurred through consumption of fecally contaminated drinking water5,19. Transmission of sporadic HEV infections is unclear34. Water contamination, food. fomites and person to person transmission may be possible factors. cases fire large epidemics is still speculative. In a study conducted in India. Santosh et al. showed protracted viremia in 4 out of 26 patients with sporadic hepatitis E. In one of these patients the fecal sample continued to remain positive for virus extraction up to the 52th day of icterus. Such cases might act as a reservoir for hepatitis E virus and are responsible for contaminating the water sources35. Detection of HEV antibodies in the sera of pigs, sheep, cattle aiid rodents in endemic areas raise a possibility of zoonosis for HEV22,26. Consumption of water sources by such domestic animals could also contribute to persistence of disease in endemic areas.
Vertical transmission of HEV infection from mother to infant is known to occur. In one stuth 6 out of 8 babies born to mothers with either acute uncomplicated hepatitis or fulminant hepatic failure in the third trimester of pregnancy were found to have evidence of HEV infection37. There is no evidence of HEV transmission by sexual contact or blood transfusion38,39.
Clinical Features
HEV has an incubation period of 2 to 10 weeks The disease manifests in a variety of forms, viz, an asymptomatic infection. anicteric hepatitis, icteric hepatitis aiid fulminant hepatic failure.
The majority of patients have an entirely asymptomatic infection without any clinical manifestations. Others have a milder clinical course with non-specific features resembling those of a viral illness (anicteric hepatitis). The exact proportion of asyniptomatic infections and anicteric hepatitis is not known but they account for the majority of cases because most sero-positive people in HEV endemic areas do not recall having had jaundice.
Acute icteric hepatitis is the most common clinically detectable form of disease. It occurs in two phases. The first, called the prodromal phase. is pre-icteric lasting a few days. It is characterized by flu-like symptoms, anorexia, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, fever, mild chills, abdominal pain. asthenia. arthralgia, aversion to smoking, a transient skin rash, clay coloured stools and dark tea coloured urine5-41. The second, the icteric phase, lasts for 1-4 weeks41 It is characterized by darkening of urine, lightening of stool colour and appearance of jaundice. Itching may also occur. With the onset of jaundice, the prodromal symptoms rapidly diminish. Physical examinations show icterus and mildly enlarged, soft and slightly tender liver and occasionally a soft palpable spleen42. Laboratory indices include bilirubinuria. a variable degree of biliruhinemia (predominantly conjugated), markedly elevated transminases and GGT and midly elevated alkaline phosphatase activity. Aminotransferase levels may start increasing upto 10 days before the onset of symptoms. peak by the end of the first week and start coming down as the illness resolves, normalizing by 6 weeks4. The magnitude of aminotransferase rise is not related to the severity of liver damage. The disease runs a self-limiting course, usually resolving in 1-4 weeks. Chronicity has not been shown to occur. However, a kw patients develop cholestasis with a prolonged clinical course. The biliruhin and alkaline phosphatase levels in these patients remain elevated with normal transaminase levels. The condition resolves in 2-6 months.
Fulminant hepatic failure develops in a small number of cases. However, this infection is an important cause of fulminant hepatitis iii endemic areas. A study conducted in India showed that HEV was responsible for 62% adult and 40% of the pediatric cases of sporadic fulminant hepatic failure. Pregnant females are especially susceptible to developing a fulminant course of this infection. In a study in Pakistan. two-thirds of a group of pregnant women with fulminant hepatic failure had HEV infection43.
Incubation period in humans after oral exposure is 2 to 10 weeks6,40. Viral antigens can be detected in the stool samples beginning approximately 1 week before onset of illness and persist for 2 weeks afterwards6,44. 1gM anti HEV appears during early clinical illness and dimminishes over 4-5 months45. lgG anti-HEV appears a few days after apperance of 1gM anti HEV and its titers remain high from 1 to 4.5 years after acute phase of the disease45. The exact duration of persistence of anti HEV is not known. One study showed 47% of people to have anti HEV 14 years after acute HEV infection46. Thus, 1gM anti HEV is a marker of acute or recent HEV infection while IgG anti HEV indicates infection, not necessarily recent.
ALT is elevated in upto 98% of the patients. The onset of ALT elevation corresponds to the detection of anti HEV in serum and decreasing levels of HEV antigens in hepatocytes. This suggest that the liver injury may be largely immune mediated, also since the infiltrating lymphocytes in the liver have been found to have a cytoxic/suppressor immunophenotype47.
The diagnosis of HEV infection utilizes clinical symptomatology (dark urine, light coloured feces and scieral icterus) along with biochemical evidence of elevated ALT levels.
HEV genome can also be detected in serum or stool samples using RT-PCR, which has recently been modified to increase the sensitivity and reproducibility. The most commonly used method is the detection of HEV antigens in serum via ELISA. Target antigens in these essays are the recombinant proteins that correspond to the open reading frame (ORF-2, ORF-3) of the genome45,48.
Preventation and Prophylaxis
Prevention of hepatitis E depends primarily on providing clean water and proper sewage disposal. Boiling water before consumption, avoiding uncooked foods and vegetables and hand washing before meals appears to be the best prophylaxis45. The protective role of anti HEV antibodies is not certain. The occurrence of HEV epidemics in disease endemic areas suggest that either anti HEV antibody is not fully protective or that antibody levels decline with time47. Immunoglobulins have been tried but their efficacy is not clear. Immunoglobulins produced in disease endemic areas do not seem to reduce disease rates in pre and post exposure prophylaxis studies49. Experimental vaccines for HEV have been developed and their effectiveness is being investigated50.
Hepatitis E is enterically transmitted causing a self-limiting illness similar to hepatitis A. However, unlike hepatitis A, immunity to hepatitis E is not life long, hepatitis E is a disease of developing nations with improper sewage disposal and unclean water supplies. It is thought to be the most common cause of acute sporadic hepatitis in Pakistan, where it has also caused major epidemics. Hepatitise causes a mild self-limiting illness with no long-term sequelae. However, it is especially severe in pregnant females in the second and third trimesters, in whom it results in a high mortality rate (up to 20%) and an increased incidence of stillbirths. Diagnosis depends on clinical findings and elevated hepatic enzymes. Protection from this disease in endemic areas lies mainly in preventation. as the vaccine for hepatitis E is still in the experimental stage. Provision of clean drinking water, hand washing before eating and proper disposal of sewage has been shown to decrease the incidence of this disease.


1.Madan K, Gopalkrishna V. Kar P. et al. Deiection of viral hepatitis C and F. virus genomes in sera of patients with acute viral hepatitis and fulminant hepatitis by their simultaneous amplification in PCR. J. Gastro. Hepatol..1983:13: 125-130.
2.Malik I. Luqman M, Ahrned A et al. A Clinico-Pathological Study of Viral Hepatitis. Pak. J. Med. Res, 1987:26:4-11.
3.Khuroo MS. Rustgu VK, Dawson GJ et al. Spectrum of hepatitis E virus infection in India. J. Mcd. Virol., 1994:43:281-6.
4.Blumer GB. Infectious hepatitis in the United States. JAMA.. 1923:49:230-4
5.Khuroo MS. Study of an epidemic of non-A. non-B type. Am. J Med.. 1980:68:818-23.
6.Balayan MS. Andjaparidze AG. Savinskaya SS et al. Evidence for a virus in non-A. non-B hepatitis transmitted via the fecal-oral route. Intervirology.1983:20:23-31.
7.Tsarev SA, Emerson SU. Reves GR ci aI. Characterization of a prototype strain of hepatitis F. virus. Proc Nati Acad Set (USA) 1992:89:559-63.
8.lqbal M. Ahrncd A. Qamar A. et al. An outbreak of entericallv transmitted non-A non-B hepatitis in Pakistan, Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg., 1989:40:438-43.
9.Van CH. Zhang HY, Tsarev RL et al. Short report: Phylogenitically distinct hepatitis E viruses in Pakistan. Am J. Trop. Med. llvg.. 2000:62:187-89.
10.Rab MA, Bile KM. Mubarik MM. et aI. Water borne hepatitis virus epidemic in Islatnabad. Pakistan A common sources outbreak traced to the malfunction ofa modern watertreatmeni plant. Am. J. Trop. Med. HYg.. 1997:57:151-157.
11.Naik SR. Aggarwal R, Salunke PN, et al. A large water borne viral hepatitis E epidemic in Kanpur. India. Bull. WHO.. 1992:70:597-599.
12.El Zimaity DMT. Hyams KC. linam IZE. et at Acute sporadic hepatitis in Egyptain pediatric population. Am J. Trop. Med Hyg 1992:48: 372-375.
13.Hyams KC, Purdy MA, Kaur M. et at. Acute sporadic hepatitis E. in Sudanese children: Analysis based on a new westrn blot assay J Infect. Dis..1992:165: 100 1-07.
14.Mc Caustland KA, Bi-S-L. Purdv MA et at. Application of two RNA extraction methods prior to amplification of hepatitis E virus nucleic acid by the polyrnerase chain reacttoti J. Virol. Methods., 1991.35.331-333.
15.Hadler SC, Margolus HS. Viral hepatitis. In Evans AS (ED): Viral infection of humans: Epidemiology and controls. 3rd ed, New York, Plenum. 1989:p. 351.
16.Mast EE, Alter MJ. Epidemiology of viral hepatitis : An overview, Sernin Virol.. 1993:4:273-275.
17.Bradley DW. Hepatitis E: Epidemiology. Aetiology and molecular biology Rev. Med. Verol.. 1992:2: 19-21.
18.Purcell RH, Ticehurst JR. Enterically transmitted non-A non—B hepatitis Epidemiology and clinical characteristics. In Zuckerman AJ (ed) Viral Hepatitis and Liver Disease New York. Alan R. Liss. 1987. p.1.
19.Tsega E. Hansoon BG, Krawczyknski K. et al. Acute sporadic viral hepatitis in Ethiopia: causes, risk factors, and effects on pregnancy. Clin Infect. Dis..1992;14 961-5.
20.Kane MA. Bradley DW. Shrestha SM. et al. Epidemic non-A, non-B hepatitis in Nepal: Recoveiy of a possible etilogy agent and transmission studies in marmosets. JAMA.. 1984:252:3140-5.
21.Lettau LA. The A, B. C, D and E of viral hepatitis: Spelling out the risk for health care workers. Infect. Control. Hosp. Epidemiol.. 1992:13:77-79.
22.Usinanov RK. Balatan MS. Kazachkov IA et al, Further study of experimental hepatitis E in piglets. Vopr. Virusol. 1994:39:208-12.
23.Dienstag JL. Alter HJ: Non-A. non-B hepatitis, evolving epidemiologic and clinical perspective Semin. Liver. E)is., 1986:6:67.
24.Cossart YE. The outcome of hepatitis B virus infection in pregnancy. Postgrad. Med.J.. 1997:53:610-13.
25.Pertez A, Paldi E, Brandstaedter S. et al. Infectious hepatitis in pregnancy. Obstct. Gynecol., 1959:14.435-41.
26.Adams RH. Coinbes R: Viral hepatitis during pregnancy. JAMA.,1965:192: 95-98.
27.Khuroo MS. Teli MR. Skidmore S. et aI. Incidence and severity of viral hepatitis in pregnancy. Am. J. Med., 1982:70: 252-55.
28Cubitt D, Bradley DW. Carter Mi et al. In vitro Propagation and Production of hepatitis E virus from in vivo-mfectcd primary macaque hepatocytes. Virology. 1996.215:1-9.
29.Koonin EV. Gorbalenya AE, Purdy MA, et al. Computer assisted assignments of functional domains in the non-structural polyprotein of hepatitis A virus: Delineation of an additional group of positive strand RNA plant and animal viruses, Proc. NatI. Acad. Sci. (USA) 1992:89:8259-63.
30.Skaug K, Hagen IJ. Von Der Lippe B. Three cases of acute hepatitis E infection imported into Norway. Scand. J. Infect. Dis., 1994:26:137-39.
31.Zaaijer IlL. KL M, Lelie PN, et al. Hepatitis E in the Netherlands: Imported and epidemic. Lancet, 1993:341:826.
32.Aggarwal R. Naik SR. Hepatitis E intrafamilial transmission versus water borne spread. i. Hepatol., 1994:21:718-23.
33.Robson SC, Adams S. Brink N, et al, Hospital outbreak of hepatitis E. Lancet, 992:339 424-5.
34.Balavan MS New forum of hepatitis with fecal-oral mode of spread. Soc. Med. Rev E. Virol., 1987.2 235.
35.Naiida SK, Ansari lH, Acharva SK. et al. Protracted viremia during acute sporadic hepatitis virus infection. Gastroentrologv. 1995;108:225-30.
36.Clavson ET, Innis BE.. Myint KS et al. Detection of hepatitis E virus infection among domestic swine in the Kathmandu Valley of Nepal Hyg.. 1995:53:228-32. Am. J. Trop. Med.
37.Khuroo MS. Karnili S. Jameel S. Vertical transmission of hepatitis E virus. Lancet, 1995:345:1025-6.
38.Psichogious M, Tzala E, l3oletis J et al. Hepatitis E virus infection in individuals at high risk of transmission on non-A non-B hepatitis and sexually transmitted diseases. Scand. J. Infect. Dis., 1996;28:443-5.
39.Barziali A, Schulman S. Karelnyi YV et al. Hepatitis E virus infection in hemophiliacs. J. Med. Virol., 1995:46:153-6.
40.Belabbes EH, Bougermouth A, Benatallah A, et al. Epidemic non-A non-B hepatitis in Algeria: Strong evidence for its spreading by water J. Med. Virol., 1985:16:256-63.
41.Vishwanathan R, Sidhu AS, Infectious hepatitis. Clinical findings. Indian,. J. Med. Res., 1957:45:(Suppl.):49-58.
42.Zhuang H, Cao X-Y, Liu C-B, et al. Entericallv transmitted non-A non-B hepatitis in China. In: Shikata T, Purcell RH, Uchida T, eds. Viral Hepatitis C. D amnd E. Amsterdam: Excerpta Medica. 1991.277-85.
43.Hamid SS. Jafri SM, Khan H et al. Fulininant hepatic failure in pregnant women: Acute fatty liver or acute viral hepatitis? J. Hepatol.. 1996:25:20-7.
44.Ticehurst J. Popkin Ti, Bryan JP, et al. Association of hepatitis F virus with an outbreak of hepatitis in Pakistan: Serological responses and patterns of vinis excretion, J Med. Virol.. 1992:36: 84-92.
45.Favorov M(.). Fields ElA. Purdy MA et al. Serlogic identification of Hepatitis E virus infection in epidemic and endemic settings. J. Infect Dis.,1989:36:246-50.
46.Khuroo MS. Kainili S. Dar MY. et al. Hepatitis E and long term antibody status (letter). Lancet., 1993:341:1355.
47.Soe S. Uchida T. Suzuki K, et al. Enterically transmitted non-A non-B hepatitis in cynomolgus monkeys: Morphology and probable mechanism of hepatocellular necrosis. Liver.. 1989:9: 135-45.
48.Li E. Zhuang H, Kolivas S. et al. Persistant and transient antibody response to hepatitis E virus detected by western immunoblot using open reading frame 2 and 3 and glutathione S-transferase fusion proteins. J. Clin. Micribiol,.1994:32:2060-6.
49.Kburoo MS. Dar MY, H lepatmtis E Evidence for person to person transmission and inability of low dose serum globulin from an Indian source to prevent it. Indian. J. Gastroentrol,, 1992:11:113-16.
50.Tsarev SA, Tsarcva TS. Emerson SU, et al. Recombinant vaccine against hepatitis E: Dose response and protection against heterologous challenge. Vaccine.. 1997:15:1834-8.

News & Events


Sindh Institute of Urology and Transplantation (SIUT), Karachi will celebrate 40 years of its services by holding an International Symposium on Recent Advances in Urology, Nephrology, GI Hepatology, Paediatrics, Transplantation & Bioethics from 8th to 12th December, 2015.Social and economic aspects of health care especially in a developing country will also be included.
Important Dates: Last date for Abstract submission:31st July 2015
Last Date for early registration: 30. September, 2015