Mubasher lkram ( Department of Otolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery, Aga Khan University Hospital, Stadium Road, Karachi. )
Jamil Hyder ( Department of Otolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery, Aga Khan University Hospital, Stadium Road, Karachi. )
Sohail Muzaffar ( Department of Otolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery, Aga Khan University Hospital, Stadium Road, Karachi. )
Sheema H. Hasan ( Department of Pathology, Aga Khan University Hospital, Stadium Road, Karachi. )
Objective: To report the efficacy of FNAC in patients with thyroid disease.
Methods: Between January 1990 and December 1994 the records of all patients treated surgically for thyroid disease at ENT Head and Neck Surgery of Aga Khan University were reviewed. All the patients had preoperative FNAC as the first line of evaluation and the histopathologist examined post-operative thyroid specimen.
Results: Forty-five patients (36 female and 9 male) had thyroid surgery. In 26 patients out of 45, FNAC was conclusive in diagnosing the nature of disease, while in 19 patients the FNAC was inconclusive because of the presence of follicular cell neoplasia.
Conclusion: Our results indicate that the FNAC is very accurate and a reliable test in the diagnosis of thyroid pathology, however, to distinguish follicular adenoma from follicular carcinoma final histology is required. FNAC is cost effective method of evaluating thyroid pathology pre-operatively and plays a vital role in planning the surgical management of thyroid nodule OPMA 49:133, 1999).
Goitre is seen in the general population, with a frequency varying between 4-10%. The prevalence of thyroid cancer is quite rare; between 3-1 1% of the thyroid pathologies will be malignant1,2. Clinicians need to recognize and distinguish between malignant lesions pre-operatively to avoid unnecessary surgery. Pre-operative identification of a malignant tumor in thyroid pathology is difficult and often unreliable. Thyroid scintigraphy, ultrasonography and biochemical tests provide little help in resolving this diagnostic problem3. Needle aspiration cytology has been used for pre-operative diagnosis for more than half a century. This method has gained worldwide acceptance during the last two decades and has been recommended as the first choice for the evaluation of thyroid pathology4-6. The cytologic criteria for papillary, medullary and anaplastic carcinoma are well defined, but the differentiation between well differentiated follicular carcinoma and follicular adenoma is not reliable by FNAC alone7,8.
Material and Methods
Between January 1990 and December 1994, the records of all patients treated surgically at Department of Otolaryngology of Aga Khan University were reviewed retrospectively. All these patients had pre-operative FNAC, as the first line of evaluation and post-operatively thyroid specimen were examined by the histopathologist. All patients in whom pre-operative FNAC was not done have been excluded from this study.
For the purpose of this study, the following definitions and diagnostic categories are used: Benign lesions include the colloid nodules, hyperplastic nodules and multinodular goiters, while malignant lesions include papillary carcinoma, medullary carcinoma, anaplastic carcinoma, lymphoma etc. For description of cytologic diagnosis, the term follicular lesion is used for both follicular adenoma and carcinoma, because cytologic separation of these entities is often impossible.
Forty-five patients, who had pre-operative FNAC of thyroid lesion and in whom post-operative histopathology was done, were selected for this study. Of 45 patients, 36 were female and 9 males. The age group varied from the teens to the seventies, the median age range was 30 to 50 years. On initial clinical presentation, 12 had solitary nodules, 13 had diffuse enlargement and 20 patients had multinodular enlargement of the thyroid gland. To assess the endocrine status of the thyroid gland, biochemical assessment was done in all these patients. Thirty-six patients were euthyroid and 9 were thyrotoxic. However, the thyroxic patients were converted into euthyroid state before surgery.
The results of FNAC are shown in Table 1.
Twenty four patients had benign lesions, 19 had follicular lesions and 2 had malignant lesions. The results of FNAC were correlated with final histology results and we found that all benign lesions reported on FNAC were benign on final histology too. In 19 patients with follicular lesions on FNAC, 2 were found to be follicular carcinoma on final histology while 17 were reported as benign follicular adenoma. The 2 patients who on FNAC had malignant nodules on FNAC were confirmed by histopathology.
Needle aspiration biopsy and direct cytologic examination from a number of organs was pioneered by Martin and Ellis in 19302. In 1952, Soderstorm used FNAC for the investigation of thyroid nodules9. It is a relatively simple technique requiring no anesthesia and is not associated with any serious complications, although the fear of needle tract implantation is possible but it is largely due to the use of large needle (18 gauge). The most commonly reported complication is a small hematoma10. Borges and Rao11 from Tata Memorial Hospital, Bombay reported no serious complication in a study of 3822 patients who had FNAC. Fine needle aspiration biopsy should be distinguished from the large needle aspiration and tru-cutt needle biopsy. The latter technique uses larger needles and specimens are processed as tissue rather than cytologic smears. They are associated with a higher complication rate and consequently not used for diagnosis of thyroid nodules.
Goitre is common, occurring in 3.2-6.5% of Western population3,12. In America, 11000 cases of thyroid carcinomas are reported every year’3 and more than 1000 people die of thyroid cancer each year14. In India thyroid cancers are 1% of all the head and neck cancers15. The percentage of malignancy in patients with thyroid pathology varies 3-1 1%3,16. The clinical challenge has been to identify the malignant nodules pre-operatively and thus minimize the indications for surgery in benign lesions.
No pre-operative test can definitely, distinguish benign from malignant thyroid nodules. The thyroid scintigraphy and ultrasound imaging has been used to identify cold nodule and cystic lesions, however most cold nodules are usually benign but 15-20% are malignant. Approximately 5-10% of warm (normofunctioning) and 20% of hot (hyperfunctioning) nodules prove to be malignant9. The majority of small cysts are benign; the incidence of malignancy in cystic lesions varies between 7- 25%9,14.
The FNAC is commonly used for the diagnosis of thyroid pathology, many authors have reported a very high ratio of accuracy. Table17-22, shows the results of different studies, the sensitivity of FNAC varies from 74.5 to 95%.
Our results indicate that the FNAC is very accurate and a reliable test in the diagnosis of thyroid pathology. With application of gold standard equation, the sensitivity and specificity for malignancy is 100% as we do not have any false positive in our study although our data is small. The problem lies in the diagnosis of the follicular lesion. To distinguish follicular adenoma from follicular carcinoma, it is essential to see the invasion of the capsule, lymphatic and blood vessels. This cannot be done through cytology. In 19 patients, follicular lesions were reported. All of them underwent surgery and in only 2 patients the follicular lesion were found to be malignant.
Our review of thyroid cases suggests, that lesions with suspicion of malignancy and follicular lesions on FNAC should undergo surgical treatment (as it is impossible to differentiate between benign and malignant follicular lesions on FNAC). We conclude, that FNAC is safe, reliable in the hands of experienced cytopathologist and cost effective method of evaluating thyroid pathology pre-operatively and plays a vital role in planning the surgical management of thyroid nodules.
1. Kingston OW, Bugis SP, Davis N. Role of frozen section and clinical parameters in distinguishing benign from malignant follicular neoplasms of the thyroid. Am. J. Surg. 1992;164:603-5
2. Dwarakanathan AA, Starsen ED,. D’Amore Mi. Importance of repeat fine needle biopsy in the management of thyroid nodules. Am. J. Surg., 1993;166:350-52.
3. Klemi Pi, Joensuu H, Nylamo E. Fine needle aspiration biopsy in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules. Acta Cytologica, 1991 ;35:434-38.
4. Bugis SP, Young JEM, Archibald SD, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of fine needle aspiration biopsy versus frozen section in solitary thyroid nodules. Am. J. Surg., 1986;152:411-16.
5. Lennquist S. The thyroid nodule, diagnosis and surgical treatment. Surg., Clin. North Am., 1987;67:213-32.
6. Silverman JF, West RL, Larkin EW. The role of fine needle aspiration biopsy in the rapid diagnosis and management of thyroid neoplasm. Cancer, 1986;57:1164-70.
7. Backdahl M, Wallin 0, Lowhagen T. Fine needle biopsy cytology and DNA analysis. Surg. Clin. North Am., 1987:67:197-211.
8. Miller JM, Kini SR, Hamburger JL. The diagnosis of malignant follicular neoplasms of the thyroid by needle biopsy. Cancer, 1985;55:2812-17.
9. Kopald KH, Layfield Li. Classifying the role of fine needle aspiration cytologic evaluation and frozen section examination in the operative management of thyroid cancer. Arch. Surg.. l989;124:1201-5.
10. Smith EH. The hazards of fine needle aspiration biopsy. Ultrasound Med. Biol. 1 984;10:629-34.
11. Brges AM, Rao S. Fine needle aspiration cytology in the management of head and neck masses. Current trends in the management of head and neck cancer, Proceedings of Tata Memorial Hospital, 1988; pp.11-24.
12. Emerick GT, Duh QY. Diagnosis, treatment and outcome of follicular thyroid carcinoma. Cancer, 1993; 72: 3287-95.
13. Silverberg E, Lubera JA. Cancer statics 1989, CA: 1989; 39:12.
14. Bouvet M, Feldman J, Gill ON. Surgical management of thyroid nodule. Patient selection based on the results of fine needle aspiration cytology. Laryngoscope, 1992;102: 1353-56.
15. Rao DN, Ganesh B. Epidemiological aspects of head and neck cancer. Current trends in the management of head and neck cancer, Bombay, Proceedings of Tata Memorial Hospital, 1988; pp.6-1 0.
16. Cersosimo E, Gharib H. Suspicious, thyroid cytologic findings, outcome in patients without immediate surgical treatment. Mayo Clin. Proc.,1993;68:343-48.
17. Gharib H. Fine needle aspiration biopsy of thyroid nodules, advantages, limitations and effect. Mayo Clin Proc., 1994;69:44-49.
18. Schmid KW, Ladurner D. Clinicopatbologic management of tumors of the thyroid gland in an endemic goiter area. Acts Cytol., 1989;33:27-30.
19. Leung CS, Hartwick RW, Bedard YC. Correlation of cytologic and histologic features in variants of papillary carcinoma of the thyroid. Acta Cytol., 1993;37:645-50.
20. Hamburger JI, Hamburger SW, Declining role of frozen section in surgical planning for thyroid nodules. Surgery, 1985;98:307-12.
21. Hawkin F, Bellido D, Bernal C. Fine needle aspiration biopsy in the diagnosis of thyroid cancer and thyroid disease, Cancer, 1987;59:1206-9.
22. Hsu C, Boey J. Diagnostic pitfalls in the tine needle aspiration of thyroid nodule, a study of 555 cases in Chinese patients. Acta Cytol., 1987;31:699-704.